Andrea Dworkin and Catharine MacKinnon: A Very Short Introduction
Andrea Rita Dworkin (September 26, 1946 – April 9, 2005) was an American radical feminist and writer best known for her criticism of pornography, which she argued was linked to rape and other forms of violence against women, and for statements that were interpreted as claiming that all heterosexual sex is rape, an interpretation she rejected. An anti-war activist and anarchist in the late 1960s, Dworkin wrote 10 books on radical feminist theory and practice. During the late 1970s and the 1980s, she gained national fame as a spokeswoman for the feminist anti-pornography movement, and for her writing on pornography and sexuality, particularly in Pornography: Men Possessing Women (1981) and Intercourse (1987), which remain her two most widely known books. Source: “Andrea Dworkin.” Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 30 Dec. 2010. Web. 5 Jan. 2011. Catharine Alice MacKinnon (born October 7, 1946) is an American feminist, scholar, lawyer, teacher and activist. MacKinnon's ideas may be divided into three central—though overlapping and ongoing—areas of focus: (1) sexual harassment, (2) pornography, and (3) international work. She has also devoted attention to social and political theory and methodology. In 1983, the Minneapolis city government hired MacKinnon and Dworkin to draft an antipornography civil rights ordinance as an amendment to the Minneapolis city civil rights ordinance. The amendment defined pornography as a civil rights violation against women, and allowed women who claimed harm from pornography to sue the producers and distributors for damages in civil court. The law was passed twice by the Minneapolis city council but vetoed by the mayor. Another version of the ordinance passed in Indianapolis, Indiana, in 1984. This ordinance was ruled unconstitutional by the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals. MacKinnon continued to support the civil rights approach in her writing and activism, and supported anti-pornography feminists who organized later campaigns in Cambridge, Massachusetts (1985) and Bellingham, Washington (1988) to pass versions of the ordinance by voter initiative. MacKinnon wrote in the Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review in 1985: And as you think about the assumption of consent that follows women into pornography, look closely some time for the skinned knees, the bruises, the welts from the whippings, the scratches, the gashes. Many of them are not simulated. One relatively soft core pornography model said, "I knew the pose was right when it hurt." It certainly seems important to the audiences that the events in the pornography be real. For this reason, pornography becomes a motive for murder, as in "snuff" films in which someone is tortured to death to make a sex film. They exist." MacKinnon represented Linda Susan Boreman (better known under her stage name of Linda Lovelace) from 1980 until her death in 2002. Civil libertarians frequently find MacKinnon's theories objectionable. They have also argued that there is no evidence that sexually explicit media encourages or promotes violence against, or other measurable harm of, women. However, Canadian researchers have demonstrated that, in subjects who are aroused by violent pornography, aggression against women increases with exposure. Source: “Catharine MacKinnon.” Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 6 Jan. 2011. Web. 6 Jan. 2011.
Dworkin: Testimony to Meese Commission 1
Dworkin: Testimony to Meese Commission 3
Dworkin: Testimony to Meese Commission 2
Dworkin: Testimony to Meese Commission 4
Web Resources about Andrea Dworkin and Catharine MacKinnon
Transcript for: A Conversation with Catharine Mackinnon
Score: 18
Summary: This
site provides readers with the extensive dialogue between Catharine MacKinnon
and PBS “Think Tank” announcer Ben Wattenberg, concerning her feministic views
and teachings. It was aired on PBS to,
“bring viewers something rare on television.”
Through this detailed discussion on a variety of topics including pornography,
women’s rights, discrimination, rape, and her works of literature, the true
identity and personality of Catharine MacKinnon is both challenged and
accurately illustrated. The discussion
provides, if nothing else, a thorough and informative introduction into the life,
opinions, and deeper motives of Catharine MacKinnon and her workings.
Evaluation: Overall, this website is extremely credible. It provides a separate and in-depth
background information page about the announcer, Ben Wattenberg. Aside from serving as an appointed delegate,
vice-chairman, and other numerous governmental positions, he once “was an aide and speech writer to President Lyndon B. Johnson from 1966 to
1968.” Wattenberg’s prestigious
accomplishments and previous experiences qualify him for this role in the
debate, as his knowledge base is, thus, more honorable. The website is sponsored by PBS, Public
Broadcasting Service, which is regularly maintained and updated. PBS is, “America’s largest public media enterprise.” The site supports scholarly
knowledge by conveying crucial information from the original speaker, allowing
readers to be fully aware and engaged in the exchange of ideas.
Prostitution and Civil Rights
Score: 18
Summary: This
speech, by Catharine MacKinnon and available electronically, was given at the Michigan Journal of Gender & Law Symposium entitled Prostitution: From Academia to
Activism. This conference held on October 31, 1992, at
the University of Michigan Law School, defines prostitution from MacKinnon’s perspective. She preaches, “In rape, the security of women's
person is stolen; in prostitution, it is stolen and sold.” While
prostitution of females is the standard case, she also addresses the existence
of male prostitution. Exploring how
prostitution denies both men and women of basic human rights, such as the right
to liberty, directly illustrates how prostitutes thus become “sexual
slaves.” Her belief that prostitution
disputes the law such as human freedom
from arbitrary arrest, property ownership, freedom of
speech, one’s basic right to be recognized as a person, equality, and several
issues in the thirteenth and fourteenth amendments are all of
central focus in this discourse.
Evaluation: This site, developed by Prostitution Research and
Education (PRE), has a goal to, “conduct
research on prostitution, pornography and trafficking, and offers education and
consultation to researchers, survivors, the public and policymakers.” Founded in 1995, the creator of this online
organization is a research and clinical
psychologist. Known and sought for help
around the world, PRE has collaborated in research projects that promote
education on prostitution. The inclusion
of footnotes at the conclusion expands upon Catharine MacKinnon’s speech,
therefore further verifying her messages and thoughts she attempted to convey
to all readers. They provide further
support and suggestions that would advance the readers understanding and
possible follow-up on the issue of prostitution and civil rights.
In Harm's Way: The Pornography Civil Rights Hearings
Score: 18
Summary: This site, edited by Catharine A. MacKinnon and Andrea Dworkin,
“is a compilation of transcripts of those hearings [on pornography and its
violations of civil rights] together with introductory material, commentary,
and related information.” In the actual transcripts of hearings provided by
this site the act of pornography is discussed in terms of production, sale, and
distribution of these materials. The violation
of basic human rights due to pornographic material is clarified by both
feminist activists. The portrayal of
women as victims of rape is yet another mentioned conviction that is supported
with an example. The other major themes
are addressed, including the Frist Amendment, “defended as it is by many, and is the target of
criticism as an instrument for pornographers to continue their oppression of
women. It is a resounding tone throughout.”
Evaluation: Published by the Law and Courts Section of
the American Political Science Association, this page was recently updated in
September of 2010. Both of the editors’
biographical and educational information is provided, verifying their
individual expertise in the area. Furthermore,
the LPBR (Law & Politics Book Review) contact information is provided on
the homepage. LPBR “has a membership of
almost 900 and presently sends the Review to over 1,300 readers in 39
countries.” Overall, sufficient information is provided in regards to the
legitimacy and dependability of the site. It promotes educational benefits by
preserving the original thoughts and teachings of MacKinnon and Dworkin.
Statement
by Catharine A.
MacKinnon And Andrea Dworkin Regarding Canadian Customs And Legal Approaches to
Pornography
Score: 17
Summary:
This article provides the statement by Catharine MacKinnon and Andrea Dworkin
on Canadian customs and the issue of pornography. The address, issued
August 26, 1994, was Women's Equality Day in the U.S. MacKinnon and Dworkin discuss the Anti-Pornography
Civil Rights Ordinance in relation to the Frist and Fourteenth Amendments,
the Supreme Court’s Butler decision, and the Canadian procedures regarding
policies and importation at the border of pornographic obscenities. The statement provides a complete analysis and
clarification of Canada’s current status on pornographic matters. Through this statement, the women hoped to ultimately
“correct the published record--and deal with the attacks, rumors,
and disinformation--surrounding the relationship of our anti-pornography
efforts to the Canadian Supreme Court's Butler decision.”
Evaluation: Sponsored by the “Institute for Global Communications,” the page is credible. On the homepage, the web-crafter, Nikki
Craft, has sufficient contact information available. The site supports the original knowledge of
MacKinnon and Dworkin for the advancement of further study and education. Since the text is derived from its original
state, the legitimacy and truthfulness aspects rise significantly. Dworkin has given Craft, the creator,
specific permission for each copyrighted text that appears. The site also offers sufficient information
about the site and its origins on the “About the Site” page. Suggestions for further exploration on
Dworkin and MacKinnon, including texts and other
works, are also included.
Catharine A. MacKinnon: The Rise of a Feminist Censor, 1983 - 1993
Score: 17
Summary: This page
offers a detailed look and analysis into the life of Catharine MacKinnon. It includes numerous quotes, arguments,
statements, and explanations of texts once spoken by her, thus offering direct
proof for the descriptions. Focusing
primarily on her teachings, beliefs, and experiences, the reader is more
inclined to understand the motives behind MacKinnon’s teachings and stances on
certain issues, as pertaining to the women’s movement. The article states, “By arguing that censorship is a legitimate tool
for attaining civil rights, she has made herself the leader of a powerful
movement to limit the protection of the First Amendment.” Advocating the first amendment is readily
addressed throughout her life, primarily in the years of the women’s movement,
as illustrated in this article. Within
the given social contexts and time periods, MacKinnon maintained a lasting
effect on the economy and way of thinking especially during this Regan
era.
Evaluation: This site is sponsored by Media Coalition, “an association that defends the First
Amendment right to produce and sell books, movies, magazines, recordings, DVDs,
videotapes, and video games, and defends the American public's First Amendment
right to have access to the broadest possible range of opinion and
entertainment.” Among the members of this educational organization include, Entertainment
Merchants Association,
Entertainment
Software Association,
Motion Picture Association of America, Inc. The legitimacy of the site is rooted in their
communicating “with federal, state and local
government officials in an effort to advise them on proposed legislation
affecting material that is protected by the First Amendment.” The executive
director of Media Coalition, David Horowitz, is provided with sufficient
contact information, as well as further information that may be relevant to the
reader of the site.
Andrea Dworkin
Score: 16
Summary: This article provides a thorough
biography of Andrea Dworkin. From her
date of birth in 1946 to her death in 2005, it offers details of her childhood,
upbringing, and involvement in the feminist movement. It discusses her involvement with abuse at
the New York's Women's House of Detention, which later became the catalyst to
her prostitution in order to make ends meet.
The many writings Dworkin authored and the inspiration/context under
which they were written are also included in the biography. Highlighting the foremost points in Dworkin’s
life, her successes and failures are accurately communicated through this
article.
Evaluation:
Sponsored by Encyclopedia of World
Biography, the information included in the biography is accurate and
credible. Yet the author, Ashyia
Henderson, lacks contact and background information, making her credentials not
as certain. However, because it is
sponsored by a known educational institution that aims to advance the knowledge
of its readers, the site becomes more legitimate. While some ads and promotions are illustrated
on the left side of the page, its review by this reputable subject directory is
of greater importance. The site was
recently updated sometime in 2011.
Pornography, Censorship, & Technology
Score: 14
Summary: This website
provides access to a variety of topics including, pornography, cyberporn,
censorship, and feminisms. Covering such
a wide array of issues as they relate to MacKinnon and Dworkin’s feminist
perspective teachings, are very beneficial to the advancement of the site’s
ideas. When discussing the women’s
anti-pornography ordinance, it briefly follows their journey, including those
opposed to their beliefs and teachings on such disputed issues, such as the Feminist Anti-Censorship Task Force (FACT) formed in
1984 in resistance to the anti-pornography ordinance. The origin on the “third wave” feminists from
the infamous sex wars are also cited on this informative website. As mentioned, “The
‘third wave’ sought to address class and race social hierarchies, as well as
those based on gender and sex.” Other possibilities
for exploration are readily available to all site users’, to further advance
one’s knowledge of Dworkin and MacKinnon.
Evaluation: On the “About” page, it is
revealed that, “This website explores the subjects
of pornography, censorship and technology as they relate to one another, focusing in
particular on the impact of the internet on pornography and its censorship.” Although its last update was in 2007, a very
detailed bibliography, works cited, works consulted, external links, are all
listed. Furthermore, all images, from “Wikimedia Commons,”
are properly cited and have the source of origin fully indicated. Although the author’s credentials are
lacking, she is still made accessible through e-mail. Finally, the site appears to be supported by
the “School of Library, Archival and Information Studies” and the University of
British Columbia, thus advancing the legitimacy of its facts and
information discussed.
Are Women Human?
Score: 13
Summary: This website offers a discussion with
Catharine A. MacKinnon’s regarding her text, “Are Women Human?” With Stuart
Jefferies as the facilitator of the conversation, he raises several questions
that are essential to her teachings from the particular book. Jefferies offers his personal opinions on
MacKinnon throughout the discussion of the text, testifying, “She is undeniably one of feminism's most
significant figures, a ferociously tough-minded lawyer and academic who has
sought to use the law to clamp down on sexual harassment and pornography.” Touching upon certain topics of rape,
pornography, public assault, discrimination, lesbianism, and questioning even
the title of her work, “Are Women Human,” Jeffries challenges MacKinnon to
define and specifically articulate her stance on such matters. Her civil rights approach dovetails her
companionship with Andrea Dworkin, as communicated in the conversation as
well.
Evaluation: The author’s profile contact
information is provided, however not to any exhausting extent. Yet, because the article is sponsored by “the
world’s leading liberal voice,” The
Guardian, it conveys credible facts and information. Promoting understating and clarification of
MacKinnon’s writing, the site also provides “Article History,” which lists the
interview’s date and time of publication.
While surrounding ads and promotions exist in the margins of the page,
the website has been maintained and updated on a consistent basis. It is copyrighted in 2011 by Guardian News and
Media Limited. Overall, the interview creates
original and scholastic advancement.
Modern Times Interview of Andrea Dworkin with Larry Josephson
Score: 12
Summary: An entire radio interview transcribed into written form for
people to read and engage with, this page is an interview with guest Andrea
Dworkin on Larry Josephson’s “American Public Radio Network.” Such a detailed and extensive account is both
light and heavy at times, certainly discussing Dworkin’s central women’s rights
beliefs as he challenges them with his own ideas, false assumptions, and preconceived
notions from a male’s perspective. A thorough discussion and look into her popular
novels, along with talk of the relation between rape and pornography is
contained in the interview. Josephson
tests the basis for Dworkin and MacKinnon’s “career,” by questioning their past
actions, teachings, and perspectives.
While conclusions are not necessarily “agreed” upon, the reader does
gain a greater understanding of Dworkin’s past and thus her resulting
intentions and actions.
Evaluation: Contact information of the website creator and host,
Nikki Craft, is provided at the conclusion of the discussion. The link directs
the user to a detailed biography and account of Nikki Craft’s life and her
journey to becoming a feminist. The page
also contains accurate citations of most references, thus legitimizing her
credibility to a greater extent. Also, the interviewer, Larry Josephson, gains authority
throughout the interview. Mentioning of his individual writings and teachings
are used for comparison to Dworkin. The website appears to be last updated 3
years ago, in 2008. The site may contain
personal biases due to personal opinion; yet, the preservation of this original
dialogue supports scholarly knowledge coming from the
original speaker.
Who Was Afraid of Andrea Dworkin?
Score: 12
Summary: Upon Andrea Dworkin’s death at the age of 58, this New York Times article was written by
her business partner and close friend, Catharine MacKinnon. As a past battered
wife, MacKinnon sheds some light on her friend’s life, literary contribution,
and underestimated level of power and admiration. In fact, “In the words
of John Berger, she was ‘perhaps the most misrepresented writer in the Western
world.’” Dworkin sought to empower women
and change their roles in such a male-dominated existence. She faced such hatred of women on a firsthand
basis, and consequently utilized this experience as justification and basis for
her beliefs. MacKinnon speaks highly of
her friend, praising her life achievements, in this article professing, “Andrea Dworkin exposed
the ugliest realities of women's lives and said what they mean.”
Evaluation: Although Catharine MacKinnon is the author of this article,
automatically creating an extreme bias, her credentials are also included. The site concludes, Catharine A. MacKinnon, "A law professor at the University of Michigan, is the author of 'Women's Lives, Men's Laws.' She was an editor, with Andrea Dworkin, of 'In Harm's Way.'" Going beyond this inherent bias, the article is published by The New York Times, which is a widely known and legitimate multimedia news engine. Although the article dates back to 2005 and consists of additional advertisements and superfluous pop-ups, the URL's and the URL's domain illustrates its reputable review prior to publication. The broader search engine is likely maintained and updated on a consistent basis. The facts and insights in the article should be read with discretion, while the author is indeed an "expert" in the field, arguably.
Content created by Rachel Neltner.